Shop
Showing 1–100 of 198 results
-
2% Milk
$2.89 – $5.29 Quick ViewSelect options -
All Purpose Flour – 5 lb
$3.65 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Almond Butter
$8.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
American Cheese
$4.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Amish Butter Cheese
$5.89 Quick ViewSelect options -
Amish Roll Butter – 1 lb
$6.69 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Apple Butter
$3.99 – $5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Apple Castle Favorites
$29.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Apple Castle Favorites Plus
$34.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Apple Fritter
$1.25 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Apple Wood Chips – Gallon Bag
$3.00 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Apples By The Basket
$7.95 – $12.00 Quick ViewSelect options -
Apples By The Pound
$1.59 Quick ViewSelect options -
Applesauce Quart
$5.99 – $6.75 Quick ViewSelect options -
Baby Swiss Cheese
$5.69 Quick ViewSelect options -
Baby White Kernel – 2 lbs
$3.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Bacon Cheese
$5.69 Quick ViewSelect options -
Bartlett Pears
$9.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Black Bean Salsa
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Blue Kernel – 2 lbs
$3.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Blueberry Cheddar Cheese
$9.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Blueberry Jam
$4.29 – $6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Bologna – All Beef
$7.29 Quick ViewSelect options -
Bologna – Garlic
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Bread – Cranberry Walnut
$5.49 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Bread – Fresh – Sliced
$2.99 – $5.49 Quick ViewSelect options -
Bread & Butter Pickles
$5.99 – $8.29 Quick ViewSelect options -
Breakfast Breads – Loaf
$6.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Brick Cheese
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Brown Eggs Dozen
$3.59 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Buns – Rolls
$3.25 – $4.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Butter Quarters – 1 lb
$5.29 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Buttermilk
$2.29 – $3.35 Quick ViewSelect options -
Cabbage – Each
$2.50 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Cake Flour – 5 lb
$3.10 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Carrots 1 lb bag
$1.49 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Cashew Butter
$6.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Cherry Berry Jam
$4.29 – $6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Chicken Breast – Buffalo Style
$7.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Chicken Breast – Oven Roasted
$7.29 Quick ViewSelect options -
Chicken Breast- Garlic & Herb
$8.39 Quick ViewSelect options -
Chicken Breast-Rotisserie Style
$7.29 Quick ViewSelect options -
Chocolate Milk
$3.19 – $5.89 Quick ViewSelect options -
Christmas Jam
$4.79 – $6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Cider Slushie
$1.50 – $2.75 Quick ViewSelect options -
Colby Cheese
$4.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Colby Jack Cheese
$4.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Corn Salsa
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Corned Beef
$11.29 Quick ViewSelect options -
Dill Spears
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Donuts
$1.35 – $11.99Quick ViewSelect optionsWhen checking out, please note any specific donuts you would like in the additional notes section. Otherwise an assortment will be chosen for you.
Donut Orders placed after 10am for same day pick-up are subject to availability. We will contact you if your specific selections are unavailable.
Our current donut flavors are:
- Apple Spice with (Cinnamon Sugar, Powder Sugar, Vanilla Frosting, Chocolate Frosting, Maple Frosting, Sprinkles)
- Old Fashioned Glazed
- Seasonal Flavor (Call for information)
-
Double Raspberry Jam
$4.29 – $6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Dry Instant Yeast (Red Label) 1 lb
$5.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Dutch Loaf
$4.69 Quick ViewSelect options -
Elderberry Jam
$4.29 – $6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Evercrisp Apples
$2.69 – $12.00 Quick ViewSelect options -
Extra Hot Pepper Mustard – Pint
$5.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Farmers Cheese
$4.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Firewood in a Banana Box
$8.00 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Focaccia Bread
$5.49 Quick ViewSelect options -
Fresh Cider
$2.00 – $7.50 Quick ViewSelect options -
FROG Jam
$4.79 – $6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Garden Veggie Yogurt Cheese
$7.89 Quick ViewSelect options -
Garlic Heads – Individual
$1.49 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Genoa Salami
$7.49 Quick ViewSelect options -
Ghost Pepper Cheese
$9.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Gingersnaps
$2.85 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Grape Jelly
$4.29 – $6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Grape Tomatoes – pint
$2.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Grapefruit- individual
$1.49 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Green Onion Cheese
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Green Tomato Relish
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Half and Half
$3.35 – $4.25 Quick ViewSelect options -
Ham – Cherrywood Smoked
$7.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Ham – Hawaiian
$7.49 Quick ViewSelect options -
Ham – Honey
$6.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Ham – Kretsmer Virginia
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Ham off the Bone
$6.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Havarti Cheese
$9.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Hickory Beefsticks – Pack of 3
$4.75 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Homestyle Beefsticks – Pack of 3
$4.75 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Honey Roasted Peanut Butter
$3.69 Quick ViewSelect options -
Honeycrisp Apple Butter – Pint
$7.49 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Horseradish Cheese
$4.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Hot Honey 1 lb
$8.49 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Hot Pepper Cheese
$4.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Hot Pepper Jam
$4.29 – $6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Hot Pepper Mustard – Pint
$5.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Hot Pepper Relish
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Hot Salsa
$5.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Iceberg Lettuce
$1.99 Quick ViewAdd to cart -
Jalapeno & Bacon Muenster Cheese
$6.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Jalepeno Eggs
$7.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Jalepeno Jelly
$6.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Jarlsberg Swiss Cheese
$10.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Lacey Baby Swiss Cheese
$4.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Lebanon Bologna
$9.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Lebanon Bologna – Sweet
$9.79 Quick ViewSelect options -
Local Raw Honey
$6.49 – $29.99 Quick ViewSelect options -
Mama Pia’s Pasta Sauce
$5.29 Quick ViewAdd to cart